|
Evaluation Criteria
The criteria used in evaluation were designed to fit the needs and
particular circumstances of this project. They are based on a combination
of the criteria for listing in the National Register of Historic Places,
for inclusion in the State Historic Resources Inventory, and for
designation as an Alameda Historical Monument. These criteria can be
divided into the broad categories of architectural significance,
historical significance, environmental significance, and design integrity.
Architectural Significance has to do with the style of a historic
resource, the reputation and ability of the architect, the quality of the
design, its uniqueness and its execution, and the materials and methods of
construction.
Historical Significance comes from an association with the lives of
persons or important events which have made a significant contribution to
the community, state or nation; or from an association with broad patterns
of cultural, social, political, economic, or industrial history; or the
urban development of Alameda.
Environmental Significance has to do with the continuity or character
of a street or neighborhood with a historical resource's setting on the
block, its landscaping, and its visual prominence as a landmark or symbol
of the city, neighborhood, or street.
Design Integrity has to do with alterations which have been made over
time to the original materials and design features of the resource.
Evaluation Procedure
The evaluators viewed each of the 10,500 buildings and sites, and
decided, based upon the evaluation criteria, whether it was significant
enough to be considered for preservation. If so, the address or
description is included in the Historical Building Study List. In
addition, the evaluators made a judgement of the quality of each historic
resource, and of whether it should be considered for preservation
individually or as a part of a grouping or neighborhood.
Use of the List
From a regulatory perspective, the List is significant for two reasons:
- The Historical Building Code applies to all properties on the
List. This offers some flexibility in building codes to preserve important
historical features.
- No building on a listed property may be demolished without prior
approval of the Historical Advisory Board. This is pursuant to Section
13-21.6 of the Alameda Municipal Code which requires that the demolition
and removal provisions relating to City Monuments shall also apply to
structures and other resources contained in the Historical Building Study
List.
The List is continually being updated and revised by the Historical
Advisory Board. Revisions to the List are filed with the City
Clerk. Affected property owners are notified prior to the Historical
Advisory Board taking any action to change the List. A property may be
removed from the List by Board action if, in the considered opinion of the
majority of the Board, a structure has been altered to such an extend as
to have removed all historic value or context.
In using this List, please note that most addresses listed are based on
field observation. Occasionally a corner building will have addresses on
two streets. Sometimes both are listed; sometimes only one. Regardless
of how it is listed, the entire parcel associated with an address is
covered by the listing.
Key to Notation
Each property on the List is preceded by an uppercase letter in
parentheses which indicates the type of historic resource located on the
property.
N - A historic resource of the highest quality, eligible for listing in
the National Register of Historic Places, usually because of its
architectural significance. These are of the highest priority for
inclusion on the list of Alameda Historical Monuments.
S - A historic resource distinguished by its architectural, historical, or
environmental significance, eligible for inclusion in the State Historic
Resources Inventory, and of secondary priority for inclusion on the list
of Alameda Historical Monuments. Many of these are also eligible for
listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Others would be
eligible if design integrity were restored.
B - A resource which, due to its scale, massing, materials, style, and
other features, is similar to a nearby "N" or "S" resource and serves as
Background support for it. These resources are eligible for inclusion in
a group or district nomination to the National Register of Historic
Places.
E - A resource which, by itself, might be insignificant, but which,
together with its neighbors, forms an Environment which is distinguished
by its continuity, its setting, its urban design features, and its
integrity. This resource derives its significance from its association
with neighboring resources.
H - A resource which may have Historical importance because of its
apparent age or location, or may have architectural importance because of
its similarity to other buildings done by important architects and/or
builders. Historic research should precede further evaluation of this
resource.
Some of the buildings and resources have been further studied by the City
or private individuals. The form or report may be on file with the City
Planning Department, and is indicated by a lowercase letter following the
address.
n - Included on the National Register of Historic Places.
np - Nomination form for National Register of Historic Places
designation has been prepared.
s - A State Historic Resources Inventory form has been prepared.
sg - A group State Historic Resources Inventory form has been prepared.
ap - An Alameda Historical Monument report has been prepared.
List (indexed by street name)
|